Here are good men’s after‑shave balms that use natural extracts (short notes on what natural ingredients they contain and which skin types they suit). I’ve included reputable product pages as sources.

1. Bulldog Sensitive / Original Aftershave Balm — aloe vera, rosehip, chamomile, green tea, cucumber oil; high % natural‑origin ingredients, fragrance‑free option for sensitive skin. Good for sensitive/dry skin. (bulldogskincare.com)

2. Proraso After‑Shave Balm (Sensitive — Green Tea & Oat) — oatmeal (Avena), green tea (Camellia sinensis), sweet almond oil, shea; alcohol‑free, formulated to soothe irritation. Good for sensitive/red‑prone skin. (bigelowtrading.com)

3. L’Occitane Cade After‑Shave Balm — shea butter, cade (quercus/cade wood) and rosemary essential oil; rich, soothing and moisturizing with woody/herbal scent. Good if you want a natural‑extract, nourishing balm. (au.loccitane.com)

4. Brickell Instant Relief Aftershave Balm — aloe vera, calendula, bilberry, jojoba oil, vitamin E and other plant extracts; marketed as natural/plant‑based and good for calming and hydrating post‑shave. Good for most skin types, especially those who prefer botanicals. (ewg.org)

5. (Other options / editors’ picks) — brands often recommended by grooming editors for natural soothing ingredients include Lab Series (contains birch/plant extracts), Proraso (already above), and brands like Weleda or SheaMoisture that emphasize plant extracts and mild formulas. Key soothing extracts to look for: aloe vera, chamomile, bisabolol, oat (avena), green tea, witch hazel, calendula, and shea butter. Avoid alcohol and strong synthetic fragrances if you have sensitive skin. (gq.com)

Quick buying tips

• For sensitive skin: prefer alcohol‑free balms that list aloe, oat, chamomile or bisabolol early in the INCI. (Proraso and Bulldog are good examples.) (bigelowtrading.com)
• For dry skin: choose balms with shea butter, glycerin, or natural oils (L’Occitane Cade, Bulldog Original). (au.loccitane.com)
• For acne/ingrown‑hair prone: look for lighter, non‑comedogenic formulas (check “non‑comedogenic” claim and avoid heavy coconut/cocoa butter if you break out). (uk.loccitane.com)

If you’d like, I can:

• Check availability and local prices in Sri Lanka (I can search local online stores and pharmacies).
• Filter by fragrance‑free or vegan options, or give a short list of the best budget vs premium picks.

Which of those would you like next?